In a shocking move that has sparked debate throughout the NFL, Tyreek Hill, the Miami Dolphins’ wide receiver, has omitted his quarterback, Tua Tagovailoa, from his top five quarterback list. The exclusion of Tagovailoa from Hill’s list has caused controversy, particularly given Hill’s earlier public endorsement of his quarterback. The drama is raising eyebrows about the friendship between the two Dolphins stars and has left everyone questioning whether there is more to it than meets the eye.
Tyreek Hill’s Top Five Quarterback List
In a Snapchat video that went viral in no time, Tyreek Hill listed his top five quarterbacks in the NFL: Patrick Mahomes, Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, and Baker Mayfield. Although the list contained some of football’s biggest names, the glaring omission was Tua Tagovailoa, Hill’s quarterback since the two signed with the Dolphins in 2022. The exclusion of Tagovailoa from Hill’s list has left fans, analysts, and teammates wondering about the dynamics of their relationship and what it bodes for the Dolphins in the future.
A Shift in Support for Tua Tagovailoa
Tyreek Hill’s attitude toward Tua has changed a lot in the last year. When Hill originally signed with the Dolphins, he was openly complimenting Tagovailoa. So much so that Hill went so far as to compare Tua’s accuracy to that of his old quarterback, Patrick Mahomes, stating that Tagovailoa’s accuracy was unique. Hill’s public endorsement was considered a powerful vote of confidence in Tua, particularly since the Dolphins attempted to construct a competitive offense around their young quarterback.
Still, Hill’s recent exclusion of Tua from his list of top quarterbacks indicates a change of heart. Although Hill has never publicly criticized his quarterback, this exclusion leaves one to wonder if he still considers Tua among the league’s elite quarterbacks. The change in Hill’s opinion may indicate unhappiness, or it may be nothing more than his individual rankings and opinions.
The Dolphins’ Struggles and What It Means for the Team
Tyreek Hill’s words and actions are coming at a precarious moment for the Miami Dolphins. Following a lackluster 2024 season where the Dolphins ended with an 8-9 record and missed the playoffs, there is mounting pressure on the team to deliver. The Dolphins possess a talented roster, but they haven’t yet managed to turn that potential into sustained success. Hill’s behavior, including his exclusion of Tua from his best quarterback list, can be an indicator of discontent in the locker room.
The backlash against Hill and Tua has raised many questions about whether there are issues beyond what appears on the surface between the two players. Whether or not Hill’s behavior was a deliberate attempt to cause trouble or merely an exercise in personal opinion, the timing of his remark is concerning about the rapport between the two players. A lack of harmony between a team’s star wide receiver and quarterback can often lead to distractions, and this controversy has the potential to impact the Dolphins as they head into the upcoming season.
Could Tyreek Hill Be Looking for a Change?
Following his comments, some have wondered if Tyreek Hill is looking for a change, either a trade or change of direction. Though there’s been no direct statement from Hill or the team suggesting that Hill is planning an exit, this absence of the former on his favorite QBs list has made everyone speculate that he might quit the Dolphins at any time. Due to high hopes from the Dolphins and his aggressive personality, Hill may actually be disappointed in the direction his team is moving in or wish for a better climate where he can flourish.
Hill, whose speed and playmaking skills are among the NFL’s best at wide receiver, is one of the league’s best wideouts, and any friction with Tagovailoa would be able to affect the team significantly. If the Dolphins are going to fight for a playoff berth and beyond, they will need their best players on the same page both on and off the field.
What’s Next for the Dolphins?
As the 2025 NFL season draws closer, the Dolphins will have to deal with this simmering drama. Though Hill’s exclusion of Tagovailoa from his best QB list may seem like a minor concern on the outside, it may be a symptom of deeper issues in the locker room. The quarterback and his best wide receiver relationship is one of the strongest in football, and if there is tension between Hill and Tagovailoa, it may travel and impact the team’s chemistry and performance.
As the season gets closer, the Dolphins will be under a microscope. Whether this controversy is merely a passing moment or the genesis of greater problems is yet to be determined. For the time being, Tyreek Hill and Tua Tagovailoa’s relationship and the direction of the Dolphins will be worth keeping an eye on as the 2025 NFL season plays out.
